Why losing a pet can feel so lonely — and what actually helps
This week The Wall Street Journal ran a column by Elizabeth Bernstein, a relationships writer, about putting down her dog Scout after almost 13 years together. (You can read it here, if you have a subscription.)
What struck us was how familiar it was. Strip out the Miami beaches and it could have been any of the families we work with in Canterbury. A dog who had been there every day for over a decade. A decision made with very little notice. Friends who sent a kind message, then went back to their lives — while the house stayed quiet.
Bernstein went looking for advice from psychologists, vets and her readers. Here is what she found, with what we see on our side of the work.
The loss is real. The support often isn't.
Psychologists have a term for grief that other people don't fully recognise: disenfranchised grief. When a person dies, there's a funeral, bereavement leave, a casserole on the doorstep. When a pet dies, there's usually none of that. You're expected to be back at work tomorrow.
But consider what a dog or cat actually was in your life. Fed by you twice a day. Asleep on your bed. There when you got home, every single time. For a lot of people living alone, a pet is the main company they have.
One line from the column has stayed with us. The author E.B. Bartels told Bernstein that when a pet dies, "we lose a witness to an era of our life." A dog who saw you through a move, a divorce, a new baby, a parent's death — that dog knew a version of you that's now gone too. It's no surprise that losing a pet can stir up older losses at the same time.
None of this needs defending. If it hurts this much, that tells you how much the animal mattered.
Take it seriously — including at work
The first piece of advice in the column is the plainest: treat this as the loss it is. Take a day off. Tell people. Join a support group if you want to talk to people who understand.
In New Zealand, bereavement leave under the Holidays Act doesn't cover pets. Plenty of employers will still give you the day if you ask, and many people use a sick day. You don't need to explain yourself beyond "my dog died yesterday."
If the weeks go by and things aren't easing — if you can't eat, can't sleep, or can't stop going over it — that's worth talking to someone about. Free call or text 1737 any time. They take pet grief seriously. We've put together more NZ pet loss support resources here, and a piece on when grief becomes something more.
The guilt is close to universal
The section of the column we'd most like every family to read is about guilt.
A psychologist Bernstein spoke to says people often blame themselves when a pet dies — especially when they chose euthanasia. The column also tells the story of a San Diego vet who had guided many families through the same decision, and still spent years blaming herself after her own dog died while she was away.
If a vet can't escape it, nobody can. We hear the same questions after almost every euthanasia:
- Did I leave it too long?
- Did I do it too soon?
- Should I have been in the room?
- Should I have tried one more treatment?
The advice in the column is to look at the whole relationship — the 13 years, not the last 13 minutes. You made the call with the information you had, on that day, for the animal in front of you. That is the job, and you did it.
We wrote about the most common regrets in more depth in 10 common regrets after pet euthanasia.
Do something to mark it
When a person dies, the funeral does a lot of work. It gives everyone a time and place to stop, say it out loud, and be sad together. With pets, families often skip this — and then wonder why it feels unfinished.
The readers who wrote to Bernstein had found their own ways:
- Keeping the ashes somewhere they see every day.
- Burying the ashes in the part of the garden the dog loved, with the family there, a few words and a song.
- Writing a long letter to the pet — the guilt, the thanks, all of it — and re-reading it later.
- Donating food and blankets to a local shelter in the pet's name.
- Writing an obituary and sharing it.
None of these need to be big. A collar on a hook, a paw print in a drawer, a walk on the beach you always did together. The point is to do something on purpose, rather than let the loss pass as if it didn't happen.
For more ideas, see 8 meaningful ways to honour a pet in New Zealand.
Write down what you're grateful for
One reader in the column, a retired psychology professor, wrote a list of ten specific things his golden retriever had added to his life — particular days, particular jokes, things that only the two of them knew. He said it brought him real peace.
It's a useful exercise because it's concrete. "I miss him" sits on your chest. "I'm grateful for the way he waited at the gate every afternoon at 3:15" is something you can actually hold. Ten items. Be specific. Keep the list.
Keep talking to them
Bernstein ends with what helped her most: wearing the engraved charm from Scout's collar on a necklace, going through photos, swapping stories with her nieces and nephews, and simply carrying on talking to her dog the way she always had.
Lots of people do this and feel a bit silly about it. You don't need to. You spoke to your pet every day for years. There's no reason to stop on the day they die.
Where we come in
We're the people who look after your pet after the vet appointment. We can't take away any of the above. What we can do is make sure the practical side gives you nothing extra to worry about:
- Your pet is tracked through every step of a 23-step process, individually numbered from the moment they leave the clinic, so you never have to wonder whose ashes came home.
- The note you write is read. If you want a blanket, a collar or a toy kept with your pet, tell us and it happens.
- A paw print or keepsake can be made as part of the process — something for the shelf, the drawer or the necklace.
- Your pet's memorial page stays online for you, for as long as you want it. Somewhere to put the photos, the obituary, the list of ten things.
If you're planning ahead for a pet who is getting older or unwell, you can arrange aftercare in advance so the decisions are made before the hard day, not during it.
The column referenced in this post is "What I Learned About Pet Grief After Losing My Dog" by Elizabeth Bernstein, published in The Wall Street Journal on 15 November 2026.


